Cash vs. CFDs in Trading Algorithms: Practical Differences and Python Code

Algorithmic trading has revolutionized the way markets operate, enabling traders to execute orders at lightning speed and implement complex strategies that are impossible to carry out manually. However, when diving into algorithmic trading, it’s crucial to understand the instruments you’re trading, particularly the difference between cash markets and Contracts for Difference (CFDs). This distinction can significantly impact your strategies and outcomes.

In this post, we’ll explore the differences between cash and CFDs and illustrate how you might approach each using Python.

Cash Market vs. CFDs: What’s the Difference?

Cash Market:

In a cash market, you are buying or selling the actual underlying asset, such as stocks, commodities, or currencies. When you buy a share of a company in the cash market, you own a portion of that company. The same goes for other assets; you own them directly.

Contracts for Difference (CFDs):

CFDs are derivative products that allow you to speculate on the price movement of an asset without owning the underlying asset. Instead of owning the stock, commodity, or currency, you enter into a contract with a broker to exchange the difference in value of an asset from the time the contract is opened to when it is closed. CFDs allow you to go long (buy) or short (sell) with leverage, often amplifying both potential profits and losses.

Key Differences:

Ownership: In the cash market, you own the asset. In CFDs, you only own a contract.
Leverage: CFDs usually involve leverage, meaning you can control a large position with a relatively small amount of capital. This isn’t the case in the cash market.
Costs: CFDs might involve additional costs, such as overnight financing charges, while owning cash assets may incur costs like dividend withholding taxes.
Market Access: CFDs often provide access to markets or instruments that might be difficult to trade directly, especially for retail traders.

Algorithmic Trading Considerations

When developing algorithmic trading strategies, the differences between cash and CFDs can significantly influence your approach:

Leverage Impact: The leverage inherent in CFDs means that your algorithms must carefully manage risk, as small price movements can lead to significant profits or losses.
Execution Costs: Algorithms need to account for additional costs associated with CFDs, such as spread, commissions, and overnight fees. These can eat into profits if not carefully managed.
Market Availability: CFDs can provide access to markets and instruments that might not be available in the cash market, allowing for more diverse strategies.

Python Example: Cash vs. CFD Strategy

To illustrate these differences, let’s consider a simple momentum-based strategy that can be applied to both cash and CFD markets. We’ll use Python and the yfinance library to backtest the strategy.

Setup:

First, ensure you have the necessary Python libraries installed:

pip install yfinance numpy pandas matplotlib

Python Code:

import yfinance as yf
import pandas as pd
import numpy as np
import matplotlib.pyplot as plt

# Function to calculate moving average crossover
def moving_average_strategy(data, short_window, long_window):
    signals = pd.DataFrame(index=data.index)
    signals['price'] = data['Close']
    signals['short_mavg'] = data['Close'].rolling(window=short_window, min_periods=1).mean()
    signals['long_mavg'] = data['Close'].rolling(window=long_window, min_periods=1).mean()
    signals['signal'] = 0.0
    signals['signal'][short_window:] = np.where(signals['short_mavg'][short_window:] > signals['long_mavg'][short_window:], 1.0, 0.0)   
    signals['positions'] = signals['signal'].diff()
    return signals

# Fetch historical data for a stock (e.g., Apple)
symbol = 'AAPL'
data = yf.download(symbol, start='2020-01-01', end='2023-01-01')

# Backtest strategy for Cash Market (no leverage)
signals_cash = moving_average_strategy(data, short_window=40, long_window=100)
initial_capital_cash = 10000
positions_cash = initial_capital_cash / data['Close']
portfolio_cash = positions_cash * data['Close']
portfolio_cash = portfolio_cash - initial_capital_cash
cash_strategy_return = portfolio_cash + initial_capital_cash

# Backtest strategy for CFDs (leverage 10:1)
leverage = 10
signals_cfd = moving_average_strategy(data, short_window=40, long_window=100)
initial_capital_cfd = 10000
positions_cfd = (initial_capital_cfd * leverage) / data['Close']
portfolio_cfd = positions_cfd * data['Close']
portfolio_cfd = portfolio_cfd - initial_capital_cfd
cfd_strategy_return = portfolio_cfd + initial_capital_cfd

# Plot the results
plt.figure(figsize=(14, 7))
plt.plot(cash_strategy_return, label='Cash Market Strategy')
plt.plot(cfd_strategy_return, label='CFD Market Strategy (10x Leverage)')
plt.title('Strategy Returns: Cash Market vs. CFDs')
plt.xlabel('Date')
plt.ylabel('Portfolio Value')
plt.legend()
plt.show()

Explanation:

Moving Average Strategy: This simple strategy buys when a short-term moving average crosses above a long-term moving average and sells when it crosses below.
Cash Market Backtest: The portfolio value is calculated assuming no leverage, and positions are adjusted according to the available capital.
CFD Market Backtest: The same strategy is applied, but with 10x leverage, meaning the trader controls a larger position size, which amplifies both potential returns and risks.

Analysis and Conclusion

The plot generated by the above code will show the difference in portfolio value over time for the cash market versus the CFD market with leverage.

In the CFD strategy, you’ll notice that the returns are more volatile due to the leverage. While this can lead to higher profits, it also increases the risk of significant losses. The cash market strategy is more stable, reflecting the direct ownership of the asset and the absence of leverage.

In algorithmic trading, the choice between cash and CFDs depends on your risk tolerance, strategy goals, and market access requirements. Understanding these differences is crucial in designing algorithms that can effectively manage risks and capitalize on market opportunities.

📚 Further Reading & Related Topics

If you’re exploring the practical differences between cash and CFDs in trading algorithms, and how to implement them in Python, these related articles will provide deeper insights:

• Mastering Risk Management in Algorithmic Trading – Learn about managing risk in both cash and CFD trading strategies with a focus on algorithmic decision-making.

• Algorithmic Trading 101: Cash Accounts vs. Margin Accounts – Explore the impact of cash vs. margin accounts in trading and how they influence leverage and risk management in algorithms.

Scalable Human Blog